Aluminium is tough and costs less, and the extra length of a 260cm probe helps when the snowpack is deep. Carbon is lighter, which ski tourers notice on a long climb, though it's less forgiving if you strike rock or ice hard.
Whichever you choose, look for a probe that assembles with a single pull and locks in a way you can manage in thick gloves, with depth markings you can read at a glance. Put it together a few times at home before your trip, because time spent fumbling in a real search is time taken away from digging. An avalanche probe is longer than a ski pole and cuts through the snow more easily, allowing you to search larger areas quickly and efficiently.

